Brussels Philharmonic | Barely Minimal

Barely Minimal

PROGRAMME NOTES

written by MAARTEN BEIRENS

Barbara Monk Feldman Northern Shore (2018)
Sarah Davachi
Oscen (2019)
Morton Feldman
Voices and Instruments I (1972)
Julius Eastman
The Holy Presence of Joan D'Arc (1981)

-----

04.10.2025 FLAGEY BRUSSELS

Music stripped to its essence—where sound meets silence, and silence becomes sound. In a world full of noise, minimalism creates space for stillness, and that’s where its power lies.
With this programme, Ilan Volkov questions the idea of ‘minimal’: what do we label as such, and what else—seen from another angle—might also be considered minimal? An experimental evening with electronics and voice as key elements.
Morton Feldman
'The space between the cracks'

Morton Feldman (1926-1987) had already built up a strong reputation as one of the core members of the close-knit New York circle around John Cage when, in 1972, he became a composition professor in Buffalo, in the far north of New York State. In the following years, the small city near the Niagara Falls would, under his impetus, grow into a place to be for composition students and other advocates of new music, with the Center for the Creative and Performing Arts and the new music festival June in Buffalo. For Feldman, this step coincided with an evolution in his music. While he had already shown a preference for softer and subtler sounds than his New York contemporaries, this tendency towards inwardness, repetition, and balance on the edge of silence became even stronger, with works such as the Viola in My Life cycle or Rothko Chapel as well-known examples. These are delicate sounds and patterns that Feldman, by repeating them almost-but-not-quite identically, or suddenly replacing them with others, kneads into a static, twilight-like musical texture.

On the surface, little seems to happen in this music. Yet the listener who opens up to Feldman’s inviting sonorities discovers, within the subtly varying patterns, a phenomenal range of tonal colours. Instead of developing or building up his material, Feldman makes time itself seem to stand still, circling for long stretches around similar elements — an interval, a harmonic combination, a figure of just a few notes. At a time when the avant-garde was captivated by strict rules and systems for shaping material, Feldman composed with striking intuition. For him, more than the logic of abstract construction, it was the sensual experience of the music that mattered. The exact blend of voices and instruments became as important as the notes they played.

In Voices and Instruments I (1972), this is evident in the unusual instrumentation (two flutes, and one each of cor anglais, clarinet, bassoon, horn, timpani, piano and double bass), alternating with the homogeneous sound of the ethereal, wordless choir. The result is gentle music, built mostly from broadly breathing chords and isolated notes. There is little in the way of melody in the traditional sense, but each new harmony arrives as an element at once soft and intensely sensual.

Feldman’s student Nils Vigeland recalls how, one day, he asked Feldman in astonishment how he could go on for twenty minutes with combinations of the same three chromatic notes (‘What about the other nine?!’), to which Feldman replied: ‘I’m looking for the space between the cracks.’ This focus on subtle qualities of sound, rather than on development, was not only picked up by Feldman’s own students but also resonated within a wider cultural movement in which repetition, stasis and incantatory musical formulas gained importance, spearheaded by American minimalism.

Barbara Monk Feldman

The Canadian composer Barbara Monk Feldman (b. 1953) went to Buffalo in 1985 to study with Feldman, and two years later—a few months before his death—married her teacher. Unsurprisingly, her music shares something of that sensuality. The Northern Shore began as a work conceived for two possible scorings: a trio of violin, piano and percussion, or as an orchestral piece in which the orchestra replaced the violin part. It proved difficult to maintain the same balance of energy between the piano and percussion on one side and either a violin or an orchestra on the other. She eventually reworked the piece, and the 2018 version leans more towards a concerto-like division of tasks between the chamber orchestra and the two soloists, but its fragile, static quality remains unmistakable.

Sarah Davachi

The same focus on detail, colour and the wealth of variation arising from combinations of sustained or repeated elements is also found in Oscen (2019) by Sarah Davachi (b. 1987). While influenced by minimalism, she too seeks a sensual listening experience, but finds it more in the psychoacoustic effects that arise when combining tones at very specific, adjusted intervals. At the opening of Oscen, repeated motifs can still be discerned, but gradually long-sustained tones take over, which, in combination with the electronic tape, create an ambient-like quality.

'Dear Joan, when meditating on your name I am given strength and dedication… I shall emancipate myself from the bind of the past and the present; I shall emancipate myself from myself.'
– Julius Eastman

Julius Eastman

Of all the composers who appeared in Buffalo during Feldman’s tenure, Julius Eastman (1940-1990) was among the most striking. He was renowned as a virtuoso singer (he made his mark with the recording of Peter Maxwell Davies’ Eight Songs for a Mad King and sang in Meredith Monk’s ensemble—his voice can still be heard on her Dolmen Music) and, as a composer, he shaped the inspirations of minimal music into something wholly his own. An outsider in many ways, as a Black gay man, he lived a flamboyant life that, during the 1980s, slid into a downward spiral of addiction and poverty: evicted from his home, he survived for a time as a homeless man in Tompkins Square Park, and eventually died almost anonymously in a Buffalo hospital. In his work he did not hesitate to harness the driving force of his repetitive style for powerful—sometimes provocative—statements. At the same time, his music contains many references to spirituality and religious symbolism. The Holy Presence of Joan d’Arc (1981), for ten cellos, is propelled from beginning to end by an unrelenting pulse, its motifs often bearing the intensity of riffs, closer to rock than to Feldman’s ethereal quality. The religious reference in the title suggests that Eastman was here searching for a form of transcendence—but one that arises from ecstatic exaltation.

LAB stretch orange web

Soundlab #1

noise and toys part 1: discover our interactive installations at the LAB-SERIES

LAB stretch frame web

LAB-SERIES

With the LAB-SERIES, the Brussels Philharmonic brings together musical experimentation, interaction, and total experience. Expect bold and eclectic concert nights with unique programmes, pre- and post-concert talks, interactive installations, and immersive listening sessions.

270234250 341093058017290 2990693525898060088 n

Score Safari: Ictus

musical pop-up with live electronics: Ictus with Tristan Perich’s Parallels before the concert Barely Minimal

Expo58 building Philips 2048x1826

Rave Little Belgium · From Expo 58’ to Techno: a Belgian history of early electronic music · 04.10.2025 · Flagey

Rave Little Belgium is a book (in the making) and a website tracing the history of electronic music in Belgium. As part of the Brussels Philharmonic LAB-SERIES, the orchestra invites founder and editor-in-chief Koen Galle — music journalist, DJ, label owner, radio host, vinyl collector, and electronic music enthusiast — to give a different lecture before each concert. In each session, he explores a unique aspect of Belgium’s rich electronic music heritage, accompanied by active listening moments.

P0kmm30x

Inside Barbara's mind

Barbara Monk Feldman: "color and silence are for me the tools for the ‘breathing’ of the music"